Legal and Institutional Frameworks for Effective Application of ADR in Marital Disputes
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53704/qmawkd31Abstract
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has emerged as a viable mechanism for resolving marital disputes in a manner that is less adversarial, more cost-effective, and emotionally considerate compared to conventional litigation.
This paper examines the legal and
institutional frameworks that support the effective application of ADR in resolving marital conflicts in Nigeria. It critically analyses statutory provisions such as the Matrimonial Causes Act, the Child Rights Act, the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023, and various rules of court which permit or encourage mediation and reconciliation in matrimonial proceedings. The study further explores the roles of key institutions, including family courts, customary and religious dispute resolution forums, and government-established bodies such as the Citizens' Mediation Centres and the Multi-Door Courthouses. By identifying the strengths and limitations of the existing frameworks, the paper highlights the potential of ADR in promoting privacy, preserving familial relationships, and ensuring outcomes that are more tailored to the interests of the parties especially in matters involving children and shared property. It also addresses challenges such as cultural resistance, lack of awareness, insufficient training of mediators, and the need for gender-sensitive approaches. The paper concludes by advocating for enhanced legal reforms, capacity-building programs, and stronger institutional synergy to make ADR a more accessible, trusted, and effective tool in the resolution of marital disputes.
References
D Bethmann and M Kvasnicka ‘The Institution of Marriage’ J Popul Econ (2011)
< https://www.jstor.org/stable/41488338 > accessed on 29 July 2024
David Blankenhorn, The Future of Marriage (Encounter books, 2007)
ibid
OM Atoyebi ‘The Legal Application of ADR in Matrimonial Disputes in Nigeria’ Series (2024) <https://omaplex.com.ng/the-legal-application-of-adr-in-matrimonial-disputes-in-nigeria-series/> accessed 29thJuly 2024
AA Oluwabiyi and OA Adewole and MO Agboke and OO Oduniyi, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) And the Settlement of Matrimonial Disputes in Nigeria’ public policy and administration research (2024) vol 14, No1 <https://iiste.org/Journals/index.php/PPAR/article/viewFile/62355/64390 >accessed 29 July 2024
Branham Chima and Constance Okorobo, ‘Marital dispute through Alternative Dispute Resolution’, University of Benin Journal (2021) https://www.researchgate.net/publication/362506089 accessed 29 July 2024
1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria (Fifth Alteration) Act, 2023 (Act N0 5).
TE Carbonneau, ‘A consideration of Alternatives to divorce Litigation’ 119 (1986).
E Akpata, ‘The Nigerian Arbitration Law in Focus’ (1997, West African Book Publisher)
CA Oputa ‘Human Rights in the Political and Legal Culture of Nigeria’ Nigerian Law Publications Ltd (1989)
OM Atoyebi ‘The Legal Application of ADR in Matrimonial Disputes in Nigeria’ Series (2024) <https://omaplex.com.ng/the-legal-application-of-adr-in-matrimonial-disputes-in-nigeria-series/> accessed 29thJuly 2024
T Carbonneau, ‘A Consideration of Alternatives to Divorce Litigation’ (1986)6 (4) (2) U.M.L Review Journal, 1119
C Okpara ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria: A Critical Analysis’. Journal of Law and Society, 2015). 42(1), 53-72.
JO Asein, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria: Prospects and Challenges’. Journal of Law and Conflict Resolution, (2012). 4(1), 1-15.
[2015] Case No 21012/TO, Court of Appeal Per OBASEKI-ADEJUMO, J.C.A. (Pp. 19-21, Paras. C-D)
K. Wilensky, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution in Matrimonial Cases’ (1995) New York Law Journal; 21
PH Gulliver, Disputes and Negotiations: A Cross-Cultural Perspective, African Press (1979)
ibid
LA Adeleke, ‘Psychotherapeutic Elements in Customary Arbitration among the Yoruba of South-Western Nigeria’ Journal of Arbitration (20191) 4(1)
ibid
TO Elias, The nature of African Customary Law, Manchester: University Press (1956) 8-9
ibid
(1998) 4 NWLR (Pt. 90) 554 at 586.
ibid
LG James, ‘The Kpelle moot: A therapeutic model for informal settlement of disputes’ Africa Journal of the
international African institute, (1963) vol. 33 1-10)
MG Smith, ‘The Economy of Hausa Communities’ Johnson Reprint Corporation (1954) 123.
AR Doi, Shariah: The Islamic Law, Ta-Ha Publishers (1984) 56.
OB Olaoba, Yoruba Legal Culture, Ibadan: FOP Press (2002)
O Adewoye, The Legal Profession in Nigeria from 1865 – 1962, London: Longman (1977), 112
A Kehinde, ‘The Lagos Multi-Door Court House and the Judge: A New Beginning’ MPJFIL (2004) 8 (340).
Adekunle Saheed Abiola, ‘The Application of Arbitration in Merger and Acquisitions Agreement: An Examination of the Problems of Consent in Parrel Proceedings’ (LLMThesis Faculty of Law Obafemi Awolowo University 2019) 13
D Peters, ‘Arbitration & Conciliation Act Companion’ (Dee-Sage Nigeria Limited, Lagos, Nigeria: 2006) 368
ibid
Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria (Fifth Alteration) Act, 2023 (Act N0 5).
D Peters, ‘Arbitration & Conciliation Act Companion’ Dee-Sage Nigeria Limited, Lagos, Nigeria: 2006, 368
[2015] Case No 21012/TO, Court of Appeal Per OBASEKI-ADEJUMO, J.C.A. (Pp. 19-21, Paras. C-D)
E.g., Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023.
E.g., National Industrial Court of Nigeria Civil Procedure Rules 2017, Order 24 of the Rules
CJ Ubanyionwu: ‘Challenges of Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria’ International Journal of Comparative Law and Legal Philosophy (IJOCLLEP) (2023) 5 (2)
Bryan Garner, ‘Black’s Law Dictionary’ West Group Publishers (1997) p. 25
Adekunle Saheed Abiola, ‘The Application of Arbitration in Merger and Acquisitions Agreement: An Examination of the Problems of Consent in Parrel Proceedings’ (LLMThesis Faculty of Law Obafemi Awolowo University 2019) 13
J Gadzama, ‘Development and Practice of ADR in Nigeria’ (2003) 1
ibid
ibid
M.T Ladan, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria: Benefits, Processes and Enforcement, Current Themes in Nigerian Law’ (paper delivered at NIALS Government Advisers, WOA, August 1997)
Britannica, ’Marriage| Definition, History, Types, Customs, Laws & Facts’ < Marriage | Definition, History, Types, Customs, Laws, & Facts | Britannica> accessed 2 December 2024
Lord Penzance in Hyde v Hyde (1866) LR 1 PD 130
D Bethmann and M Kvasnicka ‘The Institution of Marriage’ J Popul Econ (2011)
< https://www.jstor.org/stable/41488338 > accessed on 29 July 2024
((1868) LR 3 HL 55, 82.)
Ijioma v Ijioma (2009) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1156) 593 at 607)
Same Sex Marriage (Prohibition) Act 2013
AA Oluwabiyi, OA Adewole, MO Agboke and OO Oduniyi, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) And the Settlement of Matrimonial Disputes in Nigeria’ public policy and administration research (2024) 14 (1) <https://iiste.org/Journals/index.php/PPAR/article/viewFile/62355/64390 >accessed 29 July 2024
Marriage Act Cap M6 LFN 2004, Matrimonial Causes Act Cap M7 LFN 2004, Child Rights Act Cap C50, LFN 2004
IE Ohiseghame, ‘Causes and Effects of Marital Conflict in Agbado Oke Odo and Ifako Ijaye Local Council Development Areas in Lagos State’ Global Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences 9(3) 65- 76 (2021) < https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm?abstractid=3820075 > accessed 17 February 2025
ibid
SO Iroye, ‘A Critical Examination of the Causes and Management of Marital Conflicts in Nigeria’ NOUN International Journal of Peace Studies And Conflict Resolution (NIJPCR) 1(2B), August, 2021 < COMPLETE-JOURNAL-NIJPCR-VOL-1-NO-2B-FULL-PDF.pdf> accessed 17 February 2025
IE Ohiseghame, ‘Causes and Effects of Marital Conflict in Agbado Oke Odo and Ifako Ijaye Local Council Development Areas in Lagos State’ Global Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences 9(3) 65- 76 (2021) < https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm?abstractid=3820075 > accessed 17 February 2025
J Akintara, ‘Common Marital Challenges in Nigerian Marriages’ NiCREST Publications () < 6 Simple Ways To Overcome Common Marital Challenges In Nigeria> accessed 17 February 2025
SO Iroye, ‘A Critical Examination of the Causes and Management of Marital Conflicts in Nigeria’ NOUN International Journal of Peace Studies And Conflict Resolution (NIJPCR) 1(2B), August, 2021 < COMPLETE-JOURNAL-NIJPCR-VOL-1-NO-2B-FULL-PDF.pdf> accessed 17 February 2025
The Marriage Act, Laws of the Federation (LFN) 2004.
Ibid, s11
Ibid, s7
Ibid, s14
Ibid, s11
Ibid, s12
Ibid, s21
Ibid, s27
Ibid, s13
Ibid, s30
Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 (as amended) Cap. M7 LFN 2004, Section 1
Ibid, s2
Ibid sections 3,4,5
Ibid, s15
Ibid, s11
I Aina and O Oniyire , ‘Marriage Disputes in Nigeria: Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms as a Means of Resolution’ Abuad Law Review < https://djetlawyer.com/alternative-dispute-resolution-in-marriage-dispute/ > accessed 12 March 2025
Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 (as amended) Cap. M7 LFN 2004, Section 11(1) a-c
Ibid, s11
Ibid, s15
Matrimonial Causes Act 1970 (as amended) Cap. M7 LFN 2004, s2
Matrimonial Causes Rule
Ibid, Order III Rule 1
Ibid, Order III Rule 2
Ibid, Order III Rule 4
Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023, s1(1)
Ibid, s2(1 &2)
Ibid, s2(5)
(2012) 23 WRN 151
Ibid, section 64(1)
Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023
Ibid, s70(1)
Ibid, s70(2)
Ibid, s70(5)
1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria (Fifth Alteration) Act, 2023 (Act N0 5).
Ibid, section 1(1)
Ibid, section 1(3)
1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria (Fifth Alteration) Act, 2023 (Act N0 5).
Ibid, s19(d)
Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended)
S Ibrahim , YZ Mohammed, and D Halima, Examination of the Role of Nigerian Courts in ADR Process’ < https://keffi.nsuk.edu.ng/server/api/core/bitstreams/1c226631-1c53-40e5-9bec-d4b4d73c9c29/content > accessed 25 February 2025
O Agbakoba Legal, ‘Assessing The Role Of Courts In Advancing Alternative Dispute Resolution In Nigeria’ (2020) < https://oal.law/assessing-the-role-of-courts-in-advancing-alternative-dispute-resolution-in-nigeria/ > accessed 25 February 2025
Resolution System Institute(RSI), ‘Strengthening access to Justice by Enhancing Court Alternative Dispute Resolution Systems’ < https://www.aboutrsi.org/ > accessed 25 February 2025
AO Anoba, ‘The Role of the Court Under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1990’ Crescent University Law Journal (2016) 1 < https://cuab.edu.ng/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/2.-Anoba-The-Role-of-The-Court-Under-the-Arbitration-and-Conciliation-Act-1990.pdf > accessed 25 February 2025
National industrial court of Nigeria (NICN), ‘ National Industrial Court of Nigeria: Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Centre Instrument’ Lagos: The Federal Government Printer (2015) <https://nigeriareposit.nln.gov.ng/handle/20.500.14186/626 > accessed 25 February 2025
AO Anoba, ‘The Role of the Court Under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1990’ Crescent University Law Journal (2016) 1 < https://cuab.edu.ng/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/2.-Anoba-The-Role-of-The-Court-Under-the-Arbitration-and-Conciliation-Act-1990.pdf > accessed 25 February 2025
OE Osayekemwen, ‘The Role of Traditional Institutions in Conflict Resolution Among Okija People’ International Journal of Development and Management Review (2023) (18)1 <https://www.ajol.info/index.php/ijdmr/article/download/257362/243096 > accessed 13 March 2025
D.J. Francis, Peace and Conflict Studies: An African Overview of Basic Concepts in S. G. Best (ed), Introduction to Peace and Conflict Studies in West Africa (Ibadan: Spectrum Books Ltd, 2006).
E. Brems, ‘Human Rights Enforcement by People Living in Poverty: Access to Justice in Nigeria’ Journal of African Law (2010) 54(2),
TO Elias, The Nature of African Customary Law, (Manchester: University Press 1956) 8-9
LO Chukwu & KN Nwosu, ‘The Role of Lawyers in Fostering Alternative Dispute Resolution in the Multi-Door Courthouse’ (2020) Journal of Arbitrary Law 220.
A Patrick , ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria: Breaking New Boundaries’ (2023) http://abuad.edu.ng/access-to-justice-through-the-multi-doc accessed 28 February 2025
WO Egbewole, ‘ADR and International Commercial Transactions’ Modern Practice Journal of Finance and Investment Law (MPJFIL) (1999), 3 (4) 685-686.
O Abifarin, The Process and Practice of Dispute Resolution and Arbitration in Nigeria. (Princeton & Associate Publishing Co. Ltd 2021)
Ibid
D Peters, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in Nigeria - Principles and Practice, (Lagos, Dee-Sage Nig. Ltd. 2004) 171..
O Abifarin, The Process and Practice of Dispute Resolution and Arbitration in Nigeria. (Princeton & Associate Publishing Co. Ltd 2021)
Established by Section 5 of the LMDC Law
O Abifarin, The Process and Practice of Dispute Resolution and Arbitration in Nigeria. Princeton & Associate Publishing Co. Ltd (2021)
ibid
J. O. ABUSOMWAN, ‘Prospects and Challenges of Resolving Marriage Disputes through Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism’ International Review of Law and Jurisprudence (IRLJ) (2023) 5(1)
Ibid
Matrimonial Causes Act, s11
Family Court of Lagos State Civil Procedure Rules 2012
EI Nwogugu, Family law in Nigeria (Third Edition, HEBN Publishers 2014)
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/27/contents
(2023) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1906) 117
(2014), Nigeria Court of Appeal, Case No.87. Court of Appeal, Abuja

Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Azeezat Adisa

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.